| 01 | The Confessor (You Could Exist Without It) | Quiet Company |  |
| 02 | You, Me, & the Boatman (Truth Is, I’ve Been Thirsty My Whole Life) | Quiet Company | |
| 03 | Preaching to the Choir Invisible, Part I (What Do You Think Happens When We Die?) | Quiet Company | |
| 04 | Set Your Monster Free (My New Year’s Resolution Is to Cope With My Morality) | Quiet Company | |
| 05 | We Went to the Renaissance Fair (…All Our Friends Were There) | Quiet Company | |
| 06 | Fear & Fallacy Sitting In a Tree (You Were Doing Well Until Everyone Died) | Quiet Company | |
| 07 | Are You a Mirror (...Or a Window?) | Quiet Company | |
| 08 | Everything Louder Than Everything Else (Xanadu Clambake, Point Zion, Ri, Summer 2011) | Quiet Company | |
| 09 | The Black Sheep & the Shepherd (Look, I’m Just an Instrument, Okay?) | Quiet Company | |
| 10 | The Easy Confidence (What I Would Say to You Now) | Quiet Company | |
| 11 | Midnight At the Lazarus Pit (the Harlot and the Beast Are Dating!) | Quiet Company | |
| 12 | Preaching to the Choir Invisible, Part II (What Do You Think Happens When We Live?) | Quiet Company | |
| 13 | Never Tell Me the Odds (This Is the Worst Crazy Sect I’ve Ever Been In) | Quiet Company | |
| 14 | At Last! The Celestial Being Speaks (the Utterly Indifferent) | Quiet Company | |
| 15 | Perspective | Quiet Company | |
| 16 | How Do You Do It | Quiet Company | |
| 17 | Things You Already Know | Quiet Company | |
| 18 | Hold My Head Above the Water | Quiet Company | |
| 19 | Jezebel Or a Song About My Friend and That Whore He Dated | Quiet Company | |
| 20 | If You Want | Quiet Company | |
| 21 | The Biblical Sense of the Word | Quiet Company | |
