| 01 | Keep Your Christmas | Coco Hames |  |
| 02 | Green Christmas | The Essex Green | |
| 03 | Won't Be Alone Tonight | Mike Krol | |
| 04 | Down We Go (Sledding Song) | Mac McCaughan & Annie Hayden | |
| 05 | Baby in the Hay | Fruit Bats | |
| 06 | White Christmas | Apex Manor | |
| 07 | Jesus Christ | William Tyler | |
| 08 | Christmas in Prison | Hiss Golden Messenger & Lucinda Williams | |
| 09 | I Was Made for Losing You | Eric Bachmann | |
| 10 | Christmas Time Is Here (Uh Oh) | Telekinesis | |
| 11 | Christmastime Heist | Mikal Cronin | |
| 12 | Love Asked Me to Stay | Will Butler | |
| 13 | Santa, Don't Say No | Tracyanne & Danny | |
| 14 | Blue Christmas | Shout Out Louds | |
